Up until recently I would have said sex, based on what most teen girls are watching on TV. Most popular television shows being viewed by teenagers portray sex as a commonplace activity. Shows such as Grey’s Anatomy and Gossip Girl support the cultural trend for “open relationships” or “friends with benefits.” For those unused to these terms, they both loosely refer to just that – being loose (or so we used to call it), or sex without a relationship or commitment of any kind. In these television shows targeting teenagers, the message is that it is normal for girls today to have sex early and often. They suggest that physical pleasure is what you dabble in first, and if a relationship develops – well, that’s a bonus!
Recently however, I would have to give love some thought, based on what a lot of girls are reading. With an estimated 40-50 million copies in circulation, the book
Twilight and its three sequels has become a phenomenon that tips the love/sex scale when weighing what girls want. The first three books – over 400 pages each – detail only a handful of kisses and nothing more. The main characters, Bella and Edward, do eventually have sex in book four, but only after they get married – at his insistence. Why do they wait? Because Edward loves Bella and has put her moral and physical safety above their desire for physical pleasure.
Here are some excerpts … I’ve added notes in brackets for clarification.
Edward: “Do you get the feeling that everything is backward?” he laughed in my ear. “Traditionally, shouldn’t you be arguing my side [getting married], and I yours [premarital sex]?”
Bella: “That’s it isn’t it?” The short laugh that escaped me was more shocked than amused. “You’re trying to protect your virtue!” I covered my mouth with my hand to muffle the giggle that followed. The words were so… old-fashioned.
Edward: “No, silly girl,” he muttered against my shoulder. “I’m trying to protect yours. And you’re making it shockingly difficult.”
Bella: “So that’s it. You won’t sleep with me until we’re married.”
Edward: “Now, I want to do this right. Please, please, keep in mind that you’ve already agreed to this, and don’t ruin it for me.”
Bella: “Oh, no,” I gasped as he slid down onto one knee.
Edward: “Isabella Swan?” … “I promise to love you forever – every single day of forever. Will you marry me?”
There is no doubt that there is a market for Edward. Girls love him. He has all the ingredients of a television teenage heartthrob with one exception – he is a virgin and plans to keep it that way.
So, what do girls really want?
Could it possibly be that girls who read have a higher IQ and therefore make better choices than girls who watch TV? Just joking. Could it be that we are learning something about girls that media would prefer not to portray? Perhaps a sitcom about love and purity with sacrificial romance could be as hugely popular as 90210. Or are sex and drama the only way to win ratings? Author Stephenie Meyer has proved that sex is not the only way to sell books.
Time magazine recently featured an article called The Truth About Teen Girls, which directed some of the blame for what girls watch at us – the parents.
Middle school counselor Julia Taylor of North Carolina had a conversation with her sixth-graders last year that worried her. “A lot of them were watching The O.C.,” she says. “I just remember the show’s multiple sexual partners, the cocaine use, and then at the end, they drink, they drive, they set fires, but all is well! There are never any consequences.”
Taylor understands the media better than many. Her sister Mary is a producer who has worked on MTV shows including ‘My Super Sweet 16’ and ‘Spring Break.’ “I’m messing them up, and she’s fixing them,” says Mary jokingly.
But Mary also suggests that if nobody were watching the shows or buying the products that are advertised on them, they wouldn’t succeed. “We’re not ‘Little House on the Prairie’ anymore,” she says. “The world is different. If parents said, ‘You can’t watch this,’ and the ratings dropped, maybe we would change things.”
So what does your daughter want – the physical pleasure of sex, risks and all, without emotional baggage like commitment, or does she want to wait to have sex with the man who will love her and commit to her for life? Find out, ask her, advise her and then support her in making her dream come true. Unless of course she wants to go the sex-for-any-reason route – don’t support that. Tie her up and work on an arranged marriage! Just joking.
Either way, I read a great book that may help you talk with your daughter about sex. It’s called For Young Women Only: What You Need to Know About How Guys Think by Shaunti Feldhahn and Lisa A. Rice.
TELL US: If you think your daughter is too young to know what she wants, what are you preparing her to want? How do we prepare them when everything they see is advocating premarital relationships?